Tag Archives: Sergio Luzzatto

Historic Garden Varieties Continued: Western Northern Dakota Territory and Southern France

In the last couple weeks I found myself along with a small group of colleagues in Medora, western North Dakota. The four of us had a bunch of really good professional reasons for being in Medora, and as I needed to step away from the larger group to take a digital meeting phone call (complete with airpods), I decided to listen in on the digital meeting from the historic Marquis de Morès garden that the CCC built up in historic Medora, North Dakota. Just some general technical notes during the site visit.

During heritage and history nerd training with Tom Isern at North Dakota State University, one thing Isern keyed his students in on was to look for inscribed names at the bases of memorials, statues, and sculptures. Names. Years. Anything. This seemingly simple technique was used when reviewing the Marquis de Morès’ pedestal statue. On the statue east elevation, at the base of the bronze, is the first initial, surname, title, and city, that appears in this order: F. Barbedienne, Foundeur. Paris. It’s a reference to this chap who has a body of work still floating around the globe that industrial capitalists continue to help make more valuable through some sort of emotional structural demand (aka, “market forces.”).

The years that Barbedienne lived, 1810-1892, and the years that this statue would or could have come about placed in Medora, did not match: the Marquis was only in the western northern Dakota Territory badlands in the 1880s, and he got himself killed in the 1890s. Barbedienne isn’t mentioned in the index of Sergio Luzzatto’s 2026 The First Fascist (Harvard University Press), but I’ll have to see if he appears in the index of the late D. Jerome Tweton‘s previous biography of the Marquis. If you read about the character and nature of the Marquis in Luzzatto’s work, and Tweton’s work, you could imagine the Marquis creating a bronze of himself to place IN the hamlet named after his wife, daughter of the 19th century New York banking powerhouse Hoffmann. The Marquis was big on ideas and funding them with other peoples’ money. It was, as Grandpa Simpson often said, the style of the times.

Anyhow, for inscriptions: one has to migrate to the north elevation of the statue, the base, where you’ll see this inscription: POISSON. That’s Pierre-Marie Poisson (1876-1953). You can research him digitally on the French Ministry of Culture website database. So one might imagine a research question (sometimes one doesn’t have the sort of travel budget of a Marquis) that thinks about whether or not Barbedienne created some scale version of this Marquis statue while the Marquis was alive. Then this Poisson chap finds that bronze, or statue (doesn’t exactly need to be bronze), and scales it to the size we see today, and casts it. Then it sits out here in Medora. Then in the 1930s, the CCC comes along and the CCC administrator looks at this and says, “we should do a larger garden of some sort around this.” The CCC also included a drinking fountain (which is out of commission as of my site visit). But this would indeed have been a welcome hydration reprieve. Could be cool to see the fountain restored. Some day. Sounds like a project that has some work ahead of it.

Some photos of that site visit of mine of the bronze and inscribed names. At the end is an image of the drinking fountain.


Medora and Cannes: Heritage Tourism, of the Garden Variety Sort

I’m currently waiting for my family to rise for the morning, and reading Sergio Luzzatto, The First Fascist: The Sensational Life and Dark Legacy of the Marquis de Mores (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 2026), and came across a contextual description of the historic landscape architecture in Cannes, southern France, where the Marquis (aka, Tony, or Antoine de Vallombrosa — names get really altered and complex when one is born into the invented tradition of the aristocracy) romped around as a child. Luzzatto does good in providing this 1870s-ish description of the social climate of this garden. I’ll just quote Luzzatto below here in this paragraph from page 30:

Already in the late 1860s, tourist guides were calling the garden of Villa Vallombrosa one of the major attractions of Cannes, praising the generosity of the owners for allowing tourists to visit “the magnificent garden.” It was an “authentic Eden,” insisted the accounts of the early 1870s. With the efforts of the skilled horticulturists the duchess hired to manage the garden, it was soon celebrated far beyond the limits of Provence. The crowds of visitors became so large that the duke decided to establish at the entrance a system for collecting donations to benefit the local hospice. As for the duchess, despite her health problems, her reputation as the driving force behind the elegant, salon-like, charitable society gathered on the Riviera ended up earning her — in the very guide that coined the name “Côte d’ Azur” — the posthumous title “Queen of Cannes.”

So this got me remembering an on the ground visit in the western North Dakota city of Medora the 1930s Civilian Conservation Corps heritage landscape architecture that is a garden dedicated to Tony, aka, Antoine de Vallombrosa, aka, the Marquis de Mores (one can extend their pinky finger while going through this name sequence if one wants). Have a look at the photos of mine below from a couple summers ago. Was the 1930s landscape architect who guided this CCC construction in Medora imagining a sort of symbolic nod to the 1860-70s fancy garden in Cannes, France that Tony spent his childhood running in? I don’t know. But all research begins with questions.